‘Ponniyin Selvan: Part Two’ Review: Impressive Adaptation Tries to Cram Too Much Into Two Parts
Mani Ratnam wraps up Indian literary classic with action-packed sequel that includes lots of battles but feels rushed, even at 164 minutes.
By Shalini Dore
Shalini Dore
Features News Editor
- Padma Lakshmi on Designing Gold House’s Gold Gala Menu and Wanting to Show the Diversity of Indian Food 7 months ago
- Padma Lakshmi on How Immigration Intersects With Hulu’s ‘Taste the Nation’ 2 years ago
- 2023’s Top Film Schools in North America 2 years ago
When last we saw the title character of Mani Ratnam ’s epic “ Ponniyin Selvan ” saga, the real-life prince who would expand the Chola empire from South India all the way to the Ganges in the north was drowning as he crossed from Lanka to India. Instead of picking up at that cliffhanger, the action-packed second installment rewinds a few decades to focus on different characters, before circling back to reveal the fate of Jayam Ravi ’s title character, also known as Arunmozhi Varman.
Related Stories
Live Nation May Need a New Strategy, Even After Its Big Summer Season
Angelina Jolie to Star in 'Proxima' Director Alice Winocour's Next Film, Set During Paris Fashion Week (EXCLUSIVE)
Popular on variety.
Krishnamurthy’s serialized story covered several characters in the 12th century Chola dynasty and in “Part Two,” the ailing emperor Sundara Chozha (Prakash Raj) is kept almost captive in his palace by Nandini’s husband, commander Chinna Pazhuvettariyar (R. Parthiban), and his brother.
Battling the Cholas are their enemies, the Pandyas, trying to avenge their defeat some years earlier and banding with other smaller kingdoms, as well as the emperor’s nephew, Madurantakam (Rahman), who has been ruling while his uncle has been ill, and who shows aspirations to the crown.
Avoiding the Pandyas’ attempts to finish the job of eliminating Arunmozhi, his rescuers – Nambi and Poonguzhali – take him to a Buddhist monastery to recover while Vandiyadevan diverts the Pandyas and heads out to let the royal family know the prince is alive. His faithful ally brings both the crown prince Aditha and princess Kundavai to the monastery, and as Arunmozhi attempts to depart, the Pandyans descend on the town leading to a well-choreographed fight scene involving an elephant, townsfolk, a bazaar and lots of flying produce.
Exchanging fight scenes for song and dance, “Part Two” packs a lot of story into its 164-minute running time, with plenty of scheming as Nandini tries to have the emperor and his two sons killed the same night so that they won’t have time to be alerted. Her backstory is expanded to explain her actions, but some of the women from Part One, such as Princess Kundavai (Trisha Krishnan), get short shrift.
Two features spanning five and a half hours may sound like ample time to adapt “Ponniyin Selvan,” and yet, Ratnam might have been better off making this a trilogy, since the books leave so much more that he wasn’t able to include. And even though it’s billed as an A.R. Rahman musical, the song sequences are missing.
The acting is strong across the board, while costumes, production design and cinematography all serve to tell the tale fittingly. Indian artisans prove themselves to be as good as any Hollywood has to offer. A coda at the end explains how and when Arunmozhi takes over the Chola empire and builds palaces and temples, including the mighty Thanjavur temple that still stands. He moved the capital to Gangaikonda Cholapuram, named for the fact that he conquered all the way north to the Ganges.
Reviewed at Harkins Theaters Cerritos 16, Cerritos, Calif., April 29, 2023. Running time: 164 MIN.
- Production: (India) A Red Giant Movies release of a Madras Talkies, Lyca Prods. production. Producers: Mani Ratnam, Subaskaran Allirajah.
- Crew: Director: Mani Ratnam. Screenplay: Mani Ratnam, Jayamohan, Kumaravel, based on the novel "Ponniyin Selvan" by Kalki Krishnamurthy.
- With: Vikram, Jayam Ravi, Karthi, Aishwariya Rai Bachchan, Trisha Krishnan, Sobhita Dhulipala, Aishwarya Lekshmi, Jayaram, Vikram Prabhu, Sarath Kumar, R. Parthiban, Prabhu, Prakash Raj, Nassar. (Tamil dialogue)
More from Variety
Art Garfunkel Cried at Reunion Lunch With Paul Simon and Asked ‘What Happened? Why Haven’t We Seen Each Other?’: I Wanted to ‘Make Amends Before It’s Too Late’
Why Private Division’s Mystery Buyer Probably Isn’t a Gaming Giant
Apple Vision Pro Foray Into Film Won’t Define the Device
More from our brands, selena gomez spills on hiding her identity before auditions.
This $33 Million Waterfront Mansion in Miami Beach Was Inspired by Paris’s Famed Left Bank
Highest-Paid Coaches in American Sports
The Best Loofahs and Body Scrubbers, According to Dermatologists
Chicago Med Recap: Sarah Reese’s Return Resurfaces Old Issues With Charles — Plus, Is [Spoiler] a Goner?
IMAGES
VIDEO